Quality Problem/Activity


We are learning how to write "good problems" for children. So what is a good problem? Well the following is a consolidation of the last two classes' efforts to build a rubric for evaluating the quality of a good problem. This likely will not be our last attempt at writing such a rubric (afterall we are lifelong learners continually revising our thinking as we gather new information).

Sample Rubric for Evaluating the
Quality of a Problem/Activity

Characteristic/Rating

4 3 2 1
Challenge/Ability AppropriateSolution requires persistence & motivationSolution found fairly easily Solution quickly found Problem is irrelevant, not interesting, obvious, or too difficult
Multi-Step Variety of Steps and multiple means of solving; or student has flash of insight and can back up solution with rational explanationContains multi-steps for solution Contains only 2 steps for solution Contains only 1 step solution
Multi-Strategy Forces students to question & seek out alternative methodsContains several ways of reasoning May allow for exclusion of steps, but has really only 1 way to solve the problem There really is only 1 way to solve the problem
Multi-Content Integrates mathematics content and different subject areas Contains more than 2 content areas, such as operations or number, space or measurement and/or social studies, math, science Contains more than 1 content areaContains only 1 content area